4.9 (31 reviews)
Honeymoon Perfection
Clayton GA
Overall Comment
After a few days in Savannah we throughly enjoyed our stay on Tybee. We got bicycles for a few days and were perfectly located in the middle of the island. The location was perfect! The outside seating was delightful. The bed in the outer house was very comfortable.
Submitted on Mar 9, 2025
Sweetest Little Cottage
Leesburg AL
Overall Comment
I love this cottage. Perfect for a friend or sister’s getaway. Cottage had everything we needed and is just steps from the beach. Property management was extremely helpful.
Submitted on Feb 9, 2025
Peaceful Week
Mogadore OH
Overall Comment
We loved this little cottage. It had everything we needed for just the two of us. Only one downfall was that the washer was broken. The staff did offer to bring more towels if we needed it though.
Submitted on Sep 8, 2024
Perfect stay in this adorable cottage!
Hickory NC
Overall Comment
We had a fantastic vacation in this adorable cottage! Perfectly decorated and full of charm! We absolutely loved every aspect of the cottage. We had three teen girls and me; with the little cottage out back, we were fine on space, even with one bathroom. Kitchen was well stocked. We loved the location, with a quick 3 minute walk to the beach. Conveniently located to beach, groceries, restaurants, lighthouse etc. We rented bikes and rode them everywhere we went all week - perfect location! My first trip to Tybee, loved the vibe and this cottage would be my "go-to" when I come again. Thank you!
Submitted on Aug 19, 2024
Cute Cottage, Unbeatable Location
Savannah GA
Overall Comment
Old Love Cottage is exactly as described - very small, very cute, and unbelievably well located. Being a 2 minute walk from the crest section of the Tybee Beach is amazing! We also loved the separate 'main bedroom'although the middle of the night trip to the bathroom can be rough in the rain.
Only downside is that the cancellation policy through the cottage owner is different than what was shown on VRBO - make sure to double-check your dates before booking!
Submitted on Jul 25, 2024
Hot week in Tybee
Hendersonville NC
Overall Comment
1st time visiting this island & it was delightful, very hot, 110 degrees on a couple of our days. A little disappointed that the washer & dryer didn't work and the A/C couldn't take the heat. Called for maintenance assist and the no answer or way to reach them. You can def. do better with assistance while staying in cottage.
Submitted on Jul 20, 2024
Just the right size
Marvin NC
Overall Comment
Great location. I was me, my wife and our teenage son. it was small but perfect and a great location
Submitted on Jul 17, 2024
Cozy
Gastonia NC
Overall Comment
Very nice place for small family
Submitted on Jun 23, 2024
Charming Shabby Chic Cottage
Auburn GA
Overall Comment
Old Love Cottage is perfectly beachy shabby chic! The cottage is so cute and reminds me of the cottages in days past. It was very clean and comfortable. Loved the beachy colors too! The beach path is right outside the door and is just a short sandy stretch to the beach. Perfect for just the two of us.
Submitted on May 9, 2024
Anniversary trip
Overall Comment
This was by far the cutest cottage I have ever stayed in at the beach! The decor was the cutest and even though it was not on the beach it was not far to walk at all. The walk was even a pretty view! I would definitely stay here again! The cottage had everything a couple would need!
Submitted on May 5, 2024
Heavenly Honeymoon
Byrdstown TN
Overall Comment
Old Love Cottage was more than we could have ever imagined. Loved everything about our stay, and are planning on staying again. The cottage was perfect, beautiful, clean, quiet, and mere steps from the beach. Old Love cottage will not disappoint!
Submitted on Oct 16, 2023
1930 Vintage
Bradenton FL
Overall Comment
Nice stay. Mattress was uncomfortable. Otherwise great stay. Location location!!
Submitted on Oct 10, 2023
Old Love Cottage
Concord NC
Overall Comment
Loved everything about this cottage! It looks just as it’s advertised. If you like vintage & charm, then this is your place. Excellent location & extremely clean. Already planning my next visit!
Submitted on Oct 3, 2023
Quaint Cottage on the Shore
Warner Robins GA
Overall Comment
“Old Love” is a quaint cottage right on the beach. It truly is 99 steps (or 90 seconds!) because my children and I clocked it. The home has personality and is clean overall. I think it’s probably best for a couple due to its size. I stayed with my children and while there was enough bed space, it was snug.
Submitted on Sep 6, 2023
Very short walk from the beach!
Marengo IL
Overall Comment
Lovely little cabin, amazing beach access! We are already planning to return to the island next year
Submitted on Aug 7, 2023
A week in tybee
Cimarron KS
Overall Comment
It was very good.
Submitted on Jun 12, 2023
Old love cottage
Concord NH
Overall Comment
What a nice place for two people to stay, steps to the beach, friendly quiet neighbors, great location. We really enjoyed our stay,the island was easy to walk around no real need to drive unless you were going to the other end island. Denise was right, don't try to leave the island after mid morning on Saturday but we planned for that so it wasn't a problem. Would definitely consider staying there again.
Response from Tybee Cottages
HI Coleen,
So glad you enjoyed Old Love!! It is the perfect place for two people!! We loved hosting you and come again for more Tybee time when you can Thanks much, Denise and the TC Team
Submitted on May 1, 2023
Tybee Ialand Vacation
Tucker GA
Overall Comment
Old LoveCottage was within a short walk to thebeqh, qw described. As q bonus, it was a short wqlk from the cottage to on of our fqvorit restaurants. We toroughly enjyed our vacation, and wish we could come to Tybee more often.
Submitted on Apr 8, 2023
Cute little cottage!
Alton IL
Overall Comment
Cute cottage close to the beach!!
Only complaint was bathtub drain was Uber slow.
Response from Tybee Cottages
Thanks for the feedback Kim. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and will get our maintenance crew on that drain! Hope to see you back again soon, Denise & the TC Team
Submitted on Mar 29, 2023
Lovely cottage - highly recommend!
Atlanta GA
Overall Comment
Love the decor, such an adorable cottage, wake up and walk across the dunes to the ocean!!Perfection!
Submitted on Oct 26, 2022
Old Love Cottage
Cary NC
Overall Comment
The cottage was adorable and so close to the beach! Very cozy. We had a wonderful stay! The only reason for 4 stars is the scratched up Teflon pan and there was a lot of dust in the vents that should be cleaned. Otherwise I’d say it was perfect.
Submitted on Oct 22, 2022
Charming beach cabin steps from everything
Atlanta GA
Overall Comment
We stayed in Old Love Cottage, and this place is so cozy and adorable. The owners have appointed the space with tons of comfy seating, there's a small but cute and functional kitchen with everything we needed to make breakfast before heading out to the beach every morning, and we even made dinner one night with some locally caught shrimp. The space is painted white inside, and everything was clean and well taken care of. The AC worked great in both the main cabin and the smaller bedroom cabin in the back. I could hear the ocean from the back room-very soothing! There's a convenience store across the street as well as some really great restaurants, and the beach is just over the dunes with a footpath right at the front door! Denise was very helpful and quick to respond to my questions. Looking forward to staying here again.
Submitted on Sep 27, 2022
Fabulous Stay with One Flaw
Feeding Hills MA
Overall Comment
Old Love Cottage is absolutely adorable. It is very comfortable, clean and has everything you could ever need for a week's stay. Our one concern was the fact that it was hard to find by GPS. It took us 45 minutes travelling the streets to figure out that the section of the street it is on, is not found on the GPS System. We had to resort to a paper map to find our way. We called the office in a slight panic, got their voicemail, left a message that we were lost. We never, all week, received a call back. That was very disappointing and concerning.
Response from Tybee Cottages
Hi Michael,
Happy to hear you enjoyed your stay with us at Old Love. I sincerely apologize at the lack of contact back. I'm not really sure how that occurred. We do return all calls asap, usually within the hour. I could see how you would feel diappointed. Please know that is NOT in anyway our normal practice. We hope you come again and give us a second chance to have your experience a perfect 5*. Thanks so much, Denise and the TC Team.
Submitted on Jul 26, 2022
Adorable Historic Beach Cottage
Scottdale GA
Overall Comment
We enjoyed our stay at the perfectly situated Old Love Cottage. The location is amazing. The cottage is well maintained with everything needed for our stay. The floorplan is quirky, but charming and that's to be expected in a historic building.
Response from Tybee Cottages
Hi Lori,
So happy you enjoyed that quirky little OLD LOVE!! It is such an adorable beach house steps from the beach.
Please come see us again when you can.
Denise and the TC Team
Submitted on Jul 2, 2022
tybee getaway
Hampton SC
Overall Comment
awesome time. loved the rental house. will certainly go again
Submitted on Jun 15, 2022
Our Stay
Athens AL
Overall Comment
Wonderful experience. Cabin is perfect for 2 people, great beach access.
Submitted on Jun 14, 2022
Paradise
Pittsburg MO
Overall Comment
Our vacation was fabulous..our cottage was awesome..we are already talking about next year
Submitted on Jun 6, 2022
Old Love cottage
Woodbury TN
Overall Comment
I love the Old Love cottage. I have stayed 4 times now. Location is perfect. It is home away from home!!
Submitted on May 3, 2022
Great Getaway
Allensville PA
Overall Comment
We had a wonderful stay in this quaint cottage. Clean and comfortable, close to several wonderful restaurants.
Submitted on Apr 16, 2022
Quaint Cottage
Jeffersonville IN
Overall Comment
Cute little cottage with lots of charm! Only downside was the need for some minor updates and some pesky pests! We had a few roach encounters in the main house which undoubtedly made for a not-so-pleasant experience. Otherwise, the house is adorably decorated and looks exactly like the pictures
Submitted on Mar 27, 2022
Perfect Couple's Cottage
Buford GA
Overall Comment
We loved our week at "Old Love". We were there for Christmas and arrived to a beautiful Christmas tree in the cottage. The cottage is small, so cute and cozy. It was well-stocked with everything we needed and both beds were very comfy. We really loved having the beach path right outside the cottage and enjoyed walking to see the sunrise each morning. The additional "room" in the backyard is nice too. I imagined opening all the windows, feeling the ocean breeze and taking a nap out there, how nice. We would definitely stay here again, the location is fantastic !
Response from Tybee Cottages
Jennifer,
We are so happy you enjoyed your stay at our precious Old Love!! This is a charming jewel and we loved hearing that our guest enjoy it just as much. We hope to see you again soon!
Thanks so much,
Denise and the TC Crew
Submitted on Jan 4, 2022